Select Government

TX Legislative Scorecard 2023-2

The following scorecard lists several key votes in the Texas Legislature in 2023 and ranks state representatives and senators based on their fidelity to (U.S.) constitutional and limited-government principles.

Share this Legislative Scorecard in your district to inform people about the constitutionality of their elected officials' votes.

SB1070 withdraws Texas from Electronic Registration Information Center (ERIC).

The Texas State Senate passed SB1070 on May 27, 2023 by a vote of 18 to 12. We have assigned pluses to the ayes because ERIC is a George Soros-funded program that states have no business being involved with. ERIC collects private election data handed over by the states and is not transparent in how it manages that data. Instead of cleaning up the voter rolls, they inflate voter rolls significantly via private voter data.

May 27, 2023
Vote Date
View Bill Vote Text
Yes
Constitutional
Chamber

SB3 allocates $1.54 billion for border security over two years, funding law enforcement and border barriers. It includes $40 million for enhanced law enforcement in Liberty County's Colony Ridge. Funds cannot be used for land acquired through eminent domain or for barriers on such land.

The Texas State Senate passed SB3 on December 1, 2023 by a vote of 18 to 9. We have assigned pluses to the ayes because the bill strengthens border security and upholds American sovereignty. By funding enforcement and infrastructure, it counters federal policies that undermine the Constitution, deters illegal entry, and reinforces the rule of law to minimize unlawful immigration. This bill addresses the challenges of illegal immigration by safeguarding the nation’s borders and supporting policies that enhance national security rather than weaken it.

Dec 1, 2023
Vote Date
View Bill Vote Text
Yes
Constitutional
Chamber

HB900, titled the READER act, prevents sexually explicit materials from being within reach of children in government schools, and it prevents vendors from selling such materials to school districts.

The Texas State Senate Passed HB900 on May 23, 2023 by a vote of 19 to 12. We have assigned pluses to the ayes because it protects children from inappropriate content and upholds family values. By blocking sexually explicit materials in schools, the bill reinforces parents' rights in education and fosters a learning environment rooted in academic excellence and moral integrity. It also ensures taxpayer dollars won’t fund programs promoting woke culture or divisive propaganda. This legislation is a vital step toward reclaiming our schools and safeguarding our children.

May 23, 2023
Vote Date
View Bill Vote Text
Yes
Constitutional
Chamber

SB1 would create an Education Savings Account (ESA) program providing $8,000 annually per eligible child for private-education expenses, including tuition, textbooks, and tutoring.

The Texas State Senate passed SB1 on October 12, 2023 by a vote of 19 to 12. We have assigned pluses to the nays because all government money comes with strings attached. ESAs might sound good in theory, but they expand government involvement into all aspects of education — including homeschools and religious schools — and can potentially affect rules and curriculum. We encourage all parents to get their children out of government schools and instead pursue sound alternatives such as homeschooling and patriotic private schools, like FreedomProject Academy, that don’t use government funds.

Oct 12, 2023
Vote Date
View Bill Vote Text
No
Constitutional
Chamber

SB4 establishes penalties for unauthorized entry or reentry into the state by individuals classified as "aliens" under federal law, with penalties escalating for repeat offenses or previous deportations. Courts can order violators to return to their country of origin under specific conditions.

The Texas State Senate passed SB4 on November 9, 2023 by a vote of 17 to 11. We have assigned pluses to the ayes because this bill takes a strong stance against illegal reentry, reinforcing immigration laws that protect American sovereignty. By imposing penalties and curbing unlawful migration, SB4 helps counter policies that facilitate mass migration and undermine our Republic’s constitutional foundations. It also safeguards the rule of law by ensuring that immigration-law violations are met with consequences, rather than leniency, which would further erode border security and national integrity.

Nov 9, 2023
Vote Date
View Bill Vote Text
Yes
Constitutional
Chamber

SB1158 expands eligibility for funding under the Major Events Reimbursement Program by amending the Government Code to classify each series of World Cup games in a designated market area as separate, single events.

The Texas State Senate passed SB1158 on April 17, 2023 by a vote of 28 to 3. We have assigned pluses to the nays because privately-owned billion-dollar entities such as the World Cup should be expected to pay for their own facilities and events, which they can more than afford. Forcing people to furnish proliferate amounts of taxpayer money when attending games or concerts to fund crony, corporate-sponsored projects violates their individual liberties guaranteed by the Bill of Rights and the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.

Apr 17, 2023
Vote Date
View Bill Vote Text
No
Constitutional
Chamber

How did your legislators vote?

Carol Alvarado
Carol Alvarado
Democrat
Senator
Dist. SD-006
17%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Paul Bettencourt
Paul Bettencourt
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-007
67%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Brian Birdwell
Brian Birdwell
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-022
50%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Cesar Blanco
Cesar Blanco
Democrat
Senator
Dist. SD-029
20%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Donna Campbell
Donna Campbell
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-025
67%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Brandon Creighton
Brandon Creighton
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-004
67%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Sarah Eckhardt
Sarah Eckhardt
Democrat
Senator
Dist. SD-014
17%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Peter P. Flores
Peter P. Flores
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-024
67%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Roland Gutierrez
Roland Gutierrez
Democrat
Senator
Dist. SD-019
17%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Bob Hall
Bob Hall
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-002
83%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
Kelly Hancock
Kelly Hancock
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-009
67%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Juan "Chuy" Hinojosa
Juan "Chuy" Hinojosa
Democrat
Senator
Dist. SD-020
17%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Joan Huffman
Joan Huffman
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-017
67%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Bryan Hughes
Bryan Hughes
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-001
83%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
Nathan Johnson
Nathan Johnson
Democrat
Senator
Dist. SD-016
20%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Phil King
Phil King
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-010
60%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Lois Kolkhorst
Lois Kolkhorst
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-018
67%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Morgan LaMantia
Morgan LaMantia
Democrat
Senator
Dist. SD-027
17%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Jose Menendez
Jose Menendez
Democrat
Senator
Dist. SD-026
17%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Mayes Middleton
Mayes Middleton
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-011
83%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
Borris Miles
Borris Miles
Democrat
Senator
Dist. SD-013
20%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Robert Nichols
Robert Nichols
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-003
80%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Tan Parker
Tan Parker
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-012
67%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Angela Paxton
Angela Paxton
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-008
60%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Charles Perry
Charles Perry
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-028
67%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Charles Schwertner
Charles Schwertner
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-005
67%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Kevin Sparks
Kevin Sparks
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-031
67%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Drew Springer
Drew Springer
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-030
67%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Royce West
Royce West
Democrat
Senator
Dist. SD-023
17%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
John Whitmire
John Whitmire
Democrat
Senator
Dist. SD-015
25%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Judith Zaffirini
Judith Zaffirini
Democrat
Senator
Dist. SD-021
17%
Report
Score
1. ERIC Withdrawal
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Border Security
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. READER Act
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Education Savings Account
No
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. Illegal Immigration
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
6. Taxpayer-funded Events
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Get the FreedomIndex.US App

Install for faster access, or learn how this app experience works.

Learn About the App