Select Government

2025 UT Legislative Scorecard

The following scorecard lists several key votes in the Utah State Legislature in 2025 and ranks state representatives and senators based on their fidelity to (U.S.) constitutional and limited-government principles.

Share this Legislative Scorecard in your district to inform people about the constitutionality of their elected officials' votes.

Senate Votes

HB300 reshapes Utah's mail-in voting system: Voters must return mailed ballots in person to a polling place or staffed drop box and provide ID (such as a Driver's license/ID/Social Security digits), unless they opt-in for mail voting or qualify under exceptions (military/overseas). The law also sets rules on drop-box staffing and operating hours.

The Utah State Senate passed HB300 on March 6, 2025 by a vote of 19 to 10. We have assigned pluses to the ayes because unsecured drop boxes and mass mail-in voting increase the risk of electoral fraud and undermine public confidence in election integrity. By requiring in-person ballot return and voter identification, this bill strengthens election security. Under Article I, Section 4 of the U.S. Constitution, states have the authority to regulate the manner of elections, and HB300 appropriately exercises that power to ensure free, fair, and secure elections—protecting the equal voting rights of all eligible citizens.

Feb 6, 2025
Vote Date
View Bill Vote Text
Yes
Constitutional
Senate
Chamber

HB267 revokes collective‑bargaining rights for all public‑sector unions—teachers, firefighters, police, and others—by banning government employers from recognizing unions or negotiating contracts. It also imposes stricter financial reporting, limits union use of public resources, and prohibits non‑public‑employer union staff from accessing the state retirement system. The bill allows unions to continue existing membership but strips them of formal negotiating powers; it also requires public employees’ associations in the retirement system to “soft‑freeze” and pay withdrawal costs by July 1, 2027.

The Utah State Senate passed HB267 on February 6, 2025 by a vote of 16 to 13. We have assigned pluses to the ayes because collective bargaining in the public sector undermines individual liberty and accountability. Forcing employees to negotiate through unions infringes upon their freedom of association and their right to negotiate terms independently. This legislation restores individual choice, limits taxpayer-funded union privileges, and reduces government entanglement with politically driven labor organizations.

Feb 6, 2025
Vote Date
View Bill Vote Text
Yes
Constitutional
Senate
Chamber

HB81 prohibits adding fluoride to all public water systems in Utah. It also repeals existing laws that permitted fluoridation by request or in emergencies. To maintain oral health, the bill authorizes pharmacists to prescribe fluoride supplements under a statewide standing order, with required patient counseling on proper use. No public funding is provided.

The Utah State Senate passed HB81 on February 21, 2025 by a vote of 18 to 8. We have assigned pluses to the ayes because the government should not be in the business of mass medicating the public through public drinking water. Fluoride remains accessible through voluntary means—via prescription and with pharmacist guidance—without being forced on all residents. In 2020, 72.7 percent of U.S. municipal water systems contained fluoride. However, a 2012 article by The New American cited a Harvard study showing that fluoridated water “significantly” lowers children's IQ, and new research continues to confirm fluoride’s link to neurotoxicity and other serious health concerns. Government-mandated fluoridation is not only a violation of individual liberty, but increasingly shown to be a public-health risk.

Feb 21, 2025
Vote Date
View Bill Vote Text
Yes
Constitutional
Senate
Chamber

HB67 allows the state treasurer to invest up to 10% of certain public funds—including budget reserves and the Disaster Recovery Account—into precious metals. It also permits the treasurer to deduct related administrative expenses (such as vaulting and delivery fees) from investment earnings.

The Utah State Senate passed HB67 on March 3, 2025 by a vote of 19 to 6. We have assigned pluses to the ayes because this bill is an important step toward restoring constitutional money and returning to the gold standard in compliance with Article I, Section 10 of the U.S. Constitution.

Mar 3, 2025
Vote Date
View Bill Vote Text
Yes
Constitutional
Senate
Chamber

HB100 expands access to free school meals—extending no-cost lunch (and in some cases breakfast) to additional students who qualify for reduced-price meals. Around 40,000 more students will now be eligible for free lunch, and schools will participate in the federal Summer Electronic Benefits Transfer (EBT) program to help families when school lets out.

The Utah State Senate passed HB100 on March 5, 2025 by a vote of 26 to 0. We have assigned pluses to the nays because taxpayers should not be funding meals for all public-school students. This bill expands government spending and further entrenches federal involvement in state education through programs like the Summer EBT, which come with federal strings attached. By shifting the responsibility of providing meals from families to the state, it erodes personal responsibility and increases dependence on government programs, undermining both state sovereignty and parental duty.

Mar 6, 2025
Vote Date
View Bill Vote Text
No
Constitutional
Senate
Chamber

HB380 strengthens the state’s claim to broad jurisdiction over matters within Utah. It establishes a legal presumption that state rather than federal law governs most areas—including natural resources, water rights, agriculture, education, and energy—unless the U.S. Constitution explicitly assigns authority to the federal government. The bill places the burden on federal authorities to prove federal jurisdiction.

The Utah State Senate passed HB380 on March 7, 2025 by a vote of 19 to 5. We have assigned pluses to the ayes because this bill reasserts Utah’s constitutional authority to govern in areas not expressly delegated to the federal government. Under the 10th Amendment, powers not granted to the federal government are reserved to the states or the people, and the 9th Amendment affirms that individuals retain rights beyond those specifically listed in the Constitution. HB380 upholds state sovereignty by requiring the federal government to justify its authority when intervening in state-level matters.

Mar 7, 2025
Vote Date
View Bill Vote Text
Yes
Constitutional
Senate
Chamber

How did your legislators vote?

J. Stuart Adams
J. Stuart Adams
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-007
83%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Heidi Balderree
Heidi Balderree
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-013
83%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Nate Blouin
Nate Blouin
Democrat
Senator
Dist. SD-013
0%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
Brady Brammer
Brady Brammer
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-021
80%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Kirk A. Cullimore
Kirk A. Cullimore
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-019
80%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Luz Escamilla
Luz Escamilla
Democrat
Senator
Dist. SD-010
17%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
Lincoln Fillmore
Lincoln Fillmore
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-017
60%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Keith Grover
Keith Grover
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-023
83%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Wayne A. Harper
Wayne A. Harper
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-016
50%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
David P. Hinkins
David P. Hinkins
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-026
40%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Don L. Ipson
Don L. Ipson
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-029
67%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
John D. Johnson
John D. Johnson
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-003
67%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Karen Kwan
Karen Kwan
Democrat
Senator
Dist. SD-012
17%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
Daniel McCay
Daniel McCay
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-018
80%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
Mike K. McKell
Mike K. McKell
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-025
75%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Ann Millner
Ann Millner
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-005
80%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Calvin R. Musselman
Calvin R. Musselman
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-004
83%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Derrin R. Owens
Derrin R. Owens
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-027
83%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Stephanie Pitcher
Stephanie Pitcher
Democrat
Senator
Dist. SD-014
33%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
Jennifer Plumb
Jennifer Plumb
Democrat
Senator
Dist. SD-009
0%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
Kathleen A. Riebe
Kathleen A. Riebe
Democrat
Senator
Dist. SD-015
0%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
Scott D. Sandall
Scott D. Sandall
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-001
75%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
Jerry W. Stevenson
Jerry W. Stevenson
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-006
83%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Keven J. Stratton
Keven J. Stratton
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-021
83%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Daniel W. Thatcher
Daniel W. Thatcher
Senator
Dist. SD-011
50%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Evan J. Vickers
Evan J. Vickers
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-028
25%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
Todd D. Weiler
Todd D. Weiler
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-008
50%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Chris H. Wilson
Chris H. Wilson
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-002
67%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
Ronald M. Winterton
Ronald M. Winterton
Republican
Senator
Dist. SD-020
60%
Report
Score
1. Election Integrity
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
2. Public Collective Bargaining Ban
Yes
Constitutional
No
Vote Cast
3. Fluoride Ban
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
4. Real Money
Yes
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
5. "Free" School Meals
No
Constitutional
Yes
Vote Cast
6. Presumption of State Jurisdiction
Yes
Constitutional
None
Vote Cast
Get the FreedomIndex.US App

Install for faster access, or learn how this app experience works.

Learn About the App