2025 PA Legislative Scorecard

The following scorecard lists several key votes in the Pennsylvania General Assembly in 2025 and ranks state representatives and senators based on their fidelity to (U.S.) constitutional and limited-government principles.

For detailed bill descriptions and thorough explanations of their constitutional merits or violations, scan the QR code above or visit thefreedomindex.org/pa/.

Share this Legislative Scorecard in your district to inform people about the constitutionality of their elected officials' votes.

Senate Votes

1. The Day of the Bible

Designates September 12, 2025, as "The Day of the Bible" in Pennsylvania.
Read More Constitutional Vote: Yes
SR131 Roll Call 1595421

2. Regulatory Review and Accountability

Requires all state regulations costing over $1 million annually to be formally reviewed after three years.
Read More Constitutional Vote: Yes
SB444 Roll Call 1587527

3. Forced Student Loan Application

Would require all high-school seniors in Pennsylvania to complete the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA).
Read More Constitutional Vote: No
SB310 Roll Call 1570389

4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act

Requires Pennsylvania school and college sports teams to be designated by biological sex at birth, barring males from female teams and protecting schools that enforce sex-based divisions.
Read More Constitutional Vote: Yes
SB9 Roll Call 1566021

5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure

Updates poultry technician licensing by expanding eligibility to all legal U.S. residents, raising fees, granting the state agriculture secretary broader power, and strengthening enforcement.
Read More Constitutional Vote: No
HB324 Roll Call 1480773

6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal

Ends Pennsylvania's participation in RGGI by repealing CO₂ trading regulations and requiring legislative approval for any future emissions-related programs or taxes.
Read More Constitutional Vote: Yes
SB186 Roll Call 1479826

How did they vote?

David G. Argall
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-029
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Lisa Baker
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-020
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Camera C. Bartolotta
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-046
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Lisa M. Boscola
33% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-018
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Michele Brooks
83% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-050
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Rosemary M. Brown
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-040
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Amanda M. Cappelletti
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-017
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Jarrett Charles Coleman
83% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-016
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Maria Collett
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-012
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Carolyn T. Comitta
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-019
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Jay Costa
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-043
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Cris Dush
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-025
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Frank Anthony Farry
80% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-006
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Martin B. Flynn
33% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-022
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Wayne D. Fontana
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-042
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Chris Gebhard
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-048
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Arthur L. Haywood
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-004
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Vincent J. Hughes
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-007
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Scott E. Hutchinson
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-021
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
John I. Kane
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-009
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Timothy P. Kearney
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-026
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Dawn Wetzel Keefer
100% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-031
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Patty H. Kim
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-015
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Wayne Langerholc
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-035
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Daniel J. Laughlin
50% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-049
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
James Andrew Malone
25% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-036
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Scott F. Martin
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-013
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Doug Mastriano
83% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-033
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Nicholas P. Miller
33% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-014
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Katie J. Muth
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-044
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Tracy Elizabeth Pennycuick
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-024
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Kristin Lee Phillips-Hill
83% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-028
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Joseph Picozzi
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-005
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Nickolas R. Pisciottano
17% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-045
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Joe Pittman
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-041
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Devlin Robinson
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-037
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Greg Rothman
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-034
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Steven J. Santarsiero
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-010
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Nikil Saval
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-001
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Lynda J. Schlegel Culver
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-027
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Judy L. Schwank
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-011
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Patrick J. Stefano
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-032
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Sharif T. Street
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-003
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Christine M. Tartaglione
17% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-002
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Elder A. Vogel
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-047
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Judith F. Ward
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-030
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Kim L. Ward
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-039
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Anthony Hardy Williams
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-008
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Lindsey Marie Williams
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-038
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Gene Yaw
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-023
1. The Day of the Bible
2. Regulatory Review and Accountability
3. Forced Student Loan Application
4. Fairness in Women's Sports Act
5. Noncitizens in Agriculture and Licensure
6. CO2 Trading Program Repeal
Get the FreedomIndex.us App

Install for faster access, or learn how this app experience works.

Learn About the App