2023 PA Legislative Scorecard

The following scorecard lists several key votes in the Pennsylvania General Assembly in 2023 and ranks state representatives and senators based on their fidelity to (U.S.) constitutional and limited-government principles.

This is our second state-level Scorecard; the selected votes may not be reflective of legislators' overall records. Their cumulative scores will change as we add more votes. Please check regularly for updates.

Share this Legislative Scorecard in your district to inform people about the constitutionality of their elected officials' votes.

Senate Votes

1. WIC Advisory Board

Establishes a Women, Infants, and Children State Advisory Board to advise the Department of Health on the Pennsylvania Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children.
Read More Constitutional Vote: No
SB721 Roll Call 1362390

2. Parental Control

Requires school entities' governing bodies to develop a parental control policy for instructional materials and books containing sexually explicit content.
Read More Constitutional Vote: Yes
SB7 Roll Call 1356457

3. Constitution Display

Requires the governing board of a school entity to display the Preamble of the Constitution of the United States at the entrance of each school building.
Read More Constitutional Vote: Yes
SB456 Roll Call 1356439

4. Forced Student Loans

Introduces a new section in the Public School Code, requiring all students to file the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) before completing high school.
Read More Constitutional Vote: No
SB750 Roll Call 1348068

5. Dog Licenses

Makes changes to the Dog Law, notably to dog and kennel licensing, advertising the sale of dogs, strengthen penalties for Dog Law violations, and improve customer service, public safety, and animal welfare.
Read More Constitutional Vote: No
SB746 Roll Call 1345454

6. Government Loans

Establishes the Veteran-owned Business Loan Guarantee Program.
Read More Constitutional Vote: No
SB248 Roll Call 1320278

How did they vote?

David G. Argall
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-029
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Ryan P. Aument
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-036
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Lisa Baker
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-020
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Camera C. Bartolotta
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-046
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Lisa M. Boscola
33% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-018
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
James R. Brewster
17% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-045
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Michele Brooks
50% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-050
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Rosemary M. Brown
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-040
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Amanda M. Cappelletti
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-017
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Jarrett Charles Coleman
50% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-016
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Maria Collett
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-012
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Carolyn T. Comitta
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-019
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Jay Costa
17% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-043
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
James Dillon
17% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-005
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Giovanni M. DiSanto
50% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-015
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Cris Dush
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-025
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Frank Anthony Farry
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-006
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Martin B. Flynn
17% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-022
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Wayne D. Fontana
17% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-042
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Chris Gebhard
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-048
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Arthur L. Haywood
17% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-004
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Vincent J. Hughes
17% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-007
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Scott E. Hutchinson
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-021
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
John I. Kane
17% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-009
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Timothy P. Kearney
17% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-026
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Wayne Langerholc
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-035
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Daniel J. Laughlin
50% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-049
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Scott F. Martin
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-013
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Doug Mastriano
67% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-033
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Nicholas P. Miller
17% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-014
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Katie J. Muth
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-044
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Tracy Elizabeth Pennycuick
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-024
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Kristin Lee Phillips-Hill
50% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-028
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Joe Pittman
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-041
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Michael R. Regan
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-031
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Devlin Robinson
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-037
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Greg Rothman
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-034
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Steven J. Santarsiero
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-010
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Nikil Saval
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-001
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Lynda J. Schlegel Culver
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-027
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Judy L. Schwank
17% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-011
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Patrick J. Stefano
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-032
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Sharif T. Street
17% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-003
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Christine M. Tartaglione
17% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-002
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Elder A. Vogel
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-047
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Judith F. Ward
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-030
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Kim L. Ward
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-039
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Anthony Hardy Williams
33% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-008
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Lindsey Marie Williams
0% Report Score
Democrat · Dist. SD-038
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Gene Yaw
33% Report Score
Republican · Dist. SD-023
1. WIC Advisory Board
2. Parental Control
3. Constitution Display
4. Forced Student Loans
5. Dog Licenses
6. Government Loans
Get the FreedomIndex.us App

Install for faster access, or learn how this app experience works.

Learn About the App