2023 ME Legislative Scorecard

The following scorecard lists several key votes in the Maine Legislature in 2023 and ranks state representatives and senators based on their fidelity to (U.S.) constitutional and limited-government principles.

This is our second state-level Scorecard; the selected votes may not be reflective of legislators' overall records. Their cumulative scores will change as we add more votes. Please check regularly for updates.

Share this Legislative Scorecard in your district to inform people about the constitutionality of their elected officials' votes.

House Votes

1. Con-Con

Applies to Congress for an Article V convention to establish term limits and address campaign finance reform.
Read More Constitutional Vote: No
HP1448 Roll Call 1405726 Rejected 40 to 97 on Mar 6, 2024 See Article V Article VI First Amendment 10th Amendment

2. Abortion

Ensures that medical malpractice insurers in Maine cannot penalize healthcare professionals who offer reproductive health services solely because they face disciplinary actions in another state for providing those services.
Read More Constitutional Vote: No
LD616 Roll Call 1345469 Passed 79 to 66 on Jun 20, 2023 See Fifth Amendment 14th Amendment Section 1 Declaration of Independence

3. Minimum Wage

Increases the state minimum wage of $15 per hour.
Read More Constitutional Vote: No
LD1376 Roll Call 1343055 Passed 71 to 70 on Jun 12, 2023 See Fifth Amendment Ninth Amendment 14th Amendment Section 1

4. Equal Pay

Amends the Maine Equal Pay Law by prohibiting pay discrimination based on race.
Read More Constitutional Vote: No
LD1703 Roll Call 1340316 Passed 112 to 20 on Jun 6, 2023 See Fifth Amendment Ninth Amendment 14th Amendment Section 1

5. Energy Scoring System

Creates a home energy scoring system to evaluate residential building energy efficiency, estimating energy use and costs, suggesting improvements, and aligning with the US Department of Energy's standards.
Read More Constitutional Vote: No
LD1101 Roll Call 1341732 Passed 70 to 67 on Jun 8, 2023 See Fourth Amendment Fifth Amendment 14th Amendment Section 1 10th Amendment Article I Section 8

6. Hormone Therapy for Minors

Outlines the process by which minors, aged 16 and above, can provide informed consent for "gender-affirming" hormone therapy without parental or guardian consent.
Read More Constitutional Vote: No
LD535 Roll Call 1347960 Passed 71 to 65 on Jun 27, 2023 See Fifth Amendment Ninth Amendment 14th Amendment Section 1

How did they vote?

Legend: Constitutional Unconstitutional Did not vote
Name Party Score 1 2 3 4 5 6
Mana H. Abdi D 0%
Jeffrey Sean Adams R 75%
Roger Clarence Albert R 80%
John E. Andrews L 80%
Daniel J. Ankeles D 17%
Amy B. Arata R 80%
Donald J. Ardell R 100%
Poppy Arford D 17%
Mark Michael Babin R 83%
Barbara A. Bagshaw R 80%
Matthew D. Beck D N/A
Arthur L. Bell D 17%
Mark John Blier R 83%
David W. Boyer R 50%
James A. Boyle D N/A
Richard T. Bradstreet R 80%
Michael F. Brennan D 17%
William R. Bridgeo D 17%
Richard H. Campbell R 83%
Nathan Michael Carlow R 60%
Meldon H. Carmichael R 60%
Kristen S. Cloutier D 17%
Sally Cluchey D 17%
Amanda Noelle Collamore R 80%
Benjamin T. Collings D 20%
Lynn Copeland D 17%
Danny E. Costain R 100%
Lydia V. Crafts D 20%
Margaret M. Craven D 17%
Dean A. Cray R 60%
Edward Crockett D 33%
Scott W. Cyrway R 83%
Kenneth Ralph Davis R 67%
Deqa Dhalac D 25%
James F. Dill D 50%
Janice S. Dodge D 17%
Victoria W. Doudera D 17%
Gary A. Drinkwater R 80%
John E. Ducharme R 67%
Larry Charles Dunphy R 83%
Holly Eaton D 0%
William R. Faulkingham R 67%
Jessica L. Fay D 33%
Steven D. Foster R 83%
Ann Fredericks R 100%
Lois Galgay Reckitt D 0%
Joseph C. Galletta R 100%
Andrew M. Gattine D 17%
Valli D. Geiger D 17%
Traci Gere D 33%
Irene Gifford R 80%
Cheryl A. Golek D 17%
Anne P. Graham D 17%
Lori Kathryn Gramlich D 0%
Randall Adam Greenwood R 67%
Abigail W. Griffin R 83%
Timothy C. Guerrette R 67%
David G. Haggan R 67%
Randall C. Hall R 83%
Tavis Rock Hasenfus D 20%
Rachel Ann Henderson R 83%
Allison L. Hepler D 33%
Daniel J. Hobbs D 17%
Benjamin C. Hymes R 83%
Caldwell Jackson R 80%
Rebecca L. Jauch D 17%
Kathy I. Javner R 60%
Christopher J. Kessler D 17%
Amy D. Kuhn D 17%
Michel Lajoie D N/A
Scott Landry D 83%
Lucas John Lanigan R 50%
Raegan French LaRochelle D 17%
Thomas A. Lavigne R 100%
Adam R. Lee D 17%
Michael H. Lemelin R 67%
Laurel D. Libby R 100%
Grayson B. Lookner D 17%
Sheila A. Lyman R 83%
Colleen M. Madigan D 17%
Marc G. Malon D 17%
Richard Gordon Mason R 83%
Anne-Marie Mastraccio D 33%
Kristi Michele Mathieson D 25%
Ann H. Matlack D 17%
Michele Meyer D 17%
Rebecca J. Millett D 17%
Sawin Millett R 67%
Nina Azella Milliken D 20%
Karen L. Montell D 17%
Matthew W. Moonen D 17%
Stephen W. Moriarty D 33%
Joshua K. Morris R 83%
Kelly Noonan Murphy D 17%
Caleb Joshua Ness R 67%
Daniel J. Newman R 67%
Robert W. Nutting R 83%
Kevin O'Connell D 33%
Margaret M. O'Neil D 17%
Laurie Osher D 17%
Wayne R. Parry R 60%
Reagan L. Paul R 100%
Sean C. Paulhus D 0%
Chad Richard Perkins R 80%
Anne C. Perry D 25%
Joseph C. Perry D 20%
William Donohue Pluecker I 20%
Jennifer L. Poirier R 67%
Edward J. Polewarczyk R 100%
Kimberly J. Pomerleau R 83%
Jane P. Pringle D 17%
Tracy Quint R 100%
Ambureen Rana D 17%
Morgan J. Rielly D 17%
Walter N. Riseman I N/A
Tiffany D. Roberts-Lovell D 17%
Amy J. Roeder D 17%
Shelley J. Rudnicki R N/A
Walter Gerard Runte D 17%
Ronald B. Russell D 20%
Melanie F. Sachs D 17%
Suzanne M. Salisbury D 17%
Heidi H. Sampson R 83%
Holly T. Sargent D 17%
Daniel Sayre D 17%
Tammy L. Schmersal-Burgess R 80%
Daniel Joseph Shagoury D 17%
Kathy A. Shaw D 33%
Erin Sheehan D 17%
Abden S. Simmons R 67%
Charles A. Skold D 17%
Katrina J. Smith R 83%
Michael Soboleski R 83%
Holly B. Stover D 17%
Tiffany Strout R 83%
Laura D. Supica D 33%
Gregory Lewis Swallow R 100%
Rachel Talbot Ross D 17%
Maureen Fitzgerald Terry D 17%
Austin L. Theriault R 60%
James E. Thorne R 67%
Joseph F. Underwood R 80%
Mark Walker R 67%
Sophia B. Warren I 0%
Bruce A. White D 60%
James Lee White R 83%
Lynne A. Williams D 17%
Stephen J. Wood R 83%
David Woodsome R 75%
James Mark Worth D 17%
Samuel Lewis Zager D 17%
Stanley Paige Zeigler D 25%

Average Freedom Score by Party

PartyScore
Democrat20.2%
Independent10%
Libertarian80%
Republican78.3%
Get the FreedomIndex.us App

Install for faster access, or learn how this app experience works.

Learn About the App