2019-2020 Florida Legislative Scorecard

The following scorecard lists several key votes in the Florida Legislature in 2019 and 2020 and ranks state representatives and senators based on their fidelity to (U.S.) constitutional and limited-government principles.

The selected votes may not be reflective of legislators' overall records. Their cumulative scores will change as we add more votes. Please check regularly for updates.

Share this Legislative Scorecard in your district to inform people about the constitutionality of their elected officials' votes.

House Votes

1. Ending Sanctuary Cities

Ends "sanctuary city" protections and directs Florida law enforcement to work with federal authorities in cases related to illegal migration.
Read More Constitutional Vote: Yes
SB168 Roll Call 857730 Passed 68 to 44 on May 2, 2019 See Article I Section 8, Article II Section 3, and 10th Amendment

2. Expanding Use of E-Verify

Mandates employers use the E-Verify system to affirm the legal status of new hires.
Read More Constitutional Vote: Yes
SB664 Roll Call 949529 Passed 73 to 44 on Mar 11, 2020 See Article I Section 8, Article II Section 3, and 10th Amendment

3. Nanny State Nicotine Prohibitions

SB810 prohibits individuals between the ages of 18-21 from purchasing tobacco or vaping products, while additionally banning the sale of most flavored nicotine products.
Read More Constitutional Vote: No
SB810 Roll Call 949709 Passed 98 to 15 on Mar 11, 2020 See Fifth Amendment, 14th Amendment, and Declaration of Independence

4. Expanding Right-to-Work Protections

Expands right-to-work protections by requiring unions to release a member upon that member's request, in addition to other worker protections.
Read More Constitutional Vote: Yes
HB001 Roll Call 942312 Passed 63 to 50 on Mar 14, 2020 See First Amendment, Fifth Amendment, 14th Amendment, and Declaration of Independence

5. Taxpayer Financed Ad Campaign

Extends funding for the Visit Florida Marketing Corporation, an expensive advertising project funded at extensive taxpayer expense.
Read More Constitutional Vote: No
SB362 Roll Call 949249 Passed 113 to 2 on Apr 9, 2020 See Fifth Amendment, 14th Amendment, and Declaration of Independence

6. Limiting Abortion Access for Minors

Prohibits physicians from performing abortions on minors without first obtaining the consent of a parent or legal guardian.
Read More Constitutional Vote: Yes
SB404 Roll Call 928696 Passed 75 to 42 on Jul 1, 2020 See Fifth Amendment, Ninth Amendment, 14th Amendment, and Declaration of Independence

How did they vote?

Legend: Constitutional Unconstitutional Did not vote
Name Party Score 1 2 3 4 5 6
Ramon Alexander D 0%
Thad Altman R 67%
Robert Alexander Andrade R 83%
Bruce Antone D 0%
Bryan Avila R 67%
Melony M. Bell R 67%
Mike Beltran R 67%
Robert Charles Brannan R 67%
Kamia L. Brown D 0%
James Vernon Buchanan R 67%
Colleen Burton R 67%
Cord Byrd R 83%
Mike Caruso R 67%
Joe Casello D 0%
John Cortes D 0%
W. Travis Cummings R 67%
Dan Daley D 0%
Kimberly Daniels D 17%
Amber Mariano Davis R 83%
Tracie Davis D 0%
Ben Diamond D 0%
Nicola G. DiCeglie R 67%
Byron Donalds R 83%
Brad Drake R 83%
Fentrice Driskell D 0%
Bobby Dubose D 0%
Wyman Duggan R 50%
Nicholas X. Duran D 0%
Dane Eagle R 83%
Anna V. Eskamani D 0%
Javier Fernandez D 0%
Juan Alfonso Fernandez-Barquin R 67%
Elizabeth Anne Fetterhoff R 67%
Randy Fine R 67%
Jason Fischer R 67%
Heather Dawes Fitzenhagen R 50%
Joseph Geller D 0%
Joy Goff-Marcil D 0%
Margaret Good D 0%
Michael A. Gottlieb D 0%
Erin K. Grall R 83%
James W. Grant R 67%
Michael Grant R 67%
Tommy Gregory R 67%
Michael Grieco D 0%
Brett Thomas Hage R 67%
Dianne Hart-Lowman D 0%
Adam Hattersley D 0%
Walter Byran Hill R 100%
Delores Hogan Johnson D 0%
Dr. James Bush III D 17%
Blaise Ingoglia R 67%
Kristin Jacobs D 0%
Al Jacquet D 40%
Evan Jenne D 0%
Shevrin D. Jones D 0%
Dotie Joseph D 0%
Vance Arthur Aloupis, Jr. R 33%
Sam H. Killebrew R 67%
Chip LaMarca R 50%
Mike LaRosa R 67%
Chris Latvala R 60%
Thomas J. Leek R 67%
MaryLynn Magar R 67%
Randy Maggard R 60%
Ralph Massullo R 67%
Stan McClain R 67%
Lawrence McClure R 67%
Kionne L. McGhee D 0%
Amy Mercado D 0%
Wengay M. Newton D 0%
Jose R. Oliva R 67%
Anika Tene Omphroy D 20%
Toby Overdorf R 67%
Bobby Payne R 67%
Daniel Perez R 67%
Cary Pigman R 67%
Scott Plakon R 67%
Rene "Coach P" Plasencia R 33%
Cindy Polo D 0%
Tina Polsky D 0%
Mel Ponder R 67%
Sharon Pritchett D 0%
Holly Merrill Raschein R 50%
Paul Renner R 67%
Spencer Roach R 83%
Will Robinson R 67%
Ray Rodrigues R 67%
Anthony Rodriguez R 50%
Bob Rommel R 67%
Rick Roth R 67%
Anthony Sabatini R 100%
David Santiago R 67%
Jason Shoaf R 60%
David Silvers D 0%
Tyler Sirois R 67%
Emily Slosberg-King D 0%
Carlos Guillermo Smith D 0%
David A. Smith R 67%
Chris Sprowls R 67%
Charles Wesley "Chuck" Clemons, Sr. R 50%
Richard Neil Stark D 0%
Cyndi Stevenson R 67%
Charlie Stone R 67%
Jennifer Sullivan R 83%
Geraldine F. "Geri" Thompson D 0%
Jackie Toledo R 67%
Josie Tomkow R 67%
Jay Trumbull R 83%
Susan L. Valdes D 17%
Barbara A. Watson D 0%
Clovis Watson D 0%
Jennifer Webb D 0%
Matt Willhite D 0%
Patricia H. Williams D 17%
Jayer Williamson R 83%
Clay Yarborough R 67%
Ardian Zika R 67%

Average Freedom Score by Party

PartyScore
Democrat2.8%
Republican67.7%
Get the FreedomIndex.us App

Install for faster access, or learn how this app experience works.

Learn About the App